• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER

Svr Wx threat April 1-April 2 2024

Clancy

Member
Messages
2,699
Reaction score
4,837
Location
Macland, Georgia
This big ol' mishmash of storms could cause us some trouble in the next hour. They're kind of colliding with each other, in a fashion similar to what happened to the cell that eventually dropped that Conyers tornado.
1712119390010.png
 

OhOkayThen

Member
Messages
24
Reaction score
56
Location
Kentucky
I still don’t see this as a bust, like I said earlier moderate risk doesn’t mean a barrage of violent tornadoes.
The NWS never had strong words for today, as the worst messaging in the watches were “a couple strong tornadoes possible”.
Which did occur in the pds warnings, of course we won’t know the full extent of damage until tomorrow.
I’m just getting the popcorn ready for the inevitable wxtwitter sh&t storm.
Although the state of emergency was a bit head scratching, but I digress.

I mean, it is a "bust". Things never materialized as expected. In the final updated MDT zone there looks to be 1 tornado report (spread across a couple of counties). Thats definitely a bust for a tornado driven MDT risk. But "bust" doesn't mean NWS or SPC got it wrong. We all saw the same metrics. The reality is sometimes even setups that look great have fail modes. I tried to explain such to a friend today and realized it's hard to explain other than that it's just how weather works. It's an imperfect science with an insane amount of variables; especially when trying to project a potential tornado outbreak. I think it's okay to call incidents like this a bust; doesn't necessarily mean something negative or that people messed up. And on the state of emergency, Beshear throws them out like candy in weather scenerios. I believe we were under multiple this past winter.
 

UK_EF4

Member
Messages
569
Reaction score
1,307
Location
NW London
In KY, IN and OH, we really dodged a bullet. Unfortunately it looks like there was some damage, but it could have been a lot worse.

What I find interesting is that the storm mode and evolution were literally as forecast - if anything even better with a good 6 or 7 discrete storms. Yet storms really struggled to produce tornadoes. Clearly, there was something wrong with the environment, but I just can't really figure out what. That Nashville observed sounding was one of the most impressive observed soundings we've seen in a while, and I can only imagine instability would have been greater further north. Clearly we have a long way to go to fully understand tornadoes!
 

buckeye05

Member
Messages
3,303
Reaction score
5,007
Location
Colorado
Breathing a sigh of relief after this one. There’s some damage no doubt, but this didn’t come close to being as bad as it could have. The Ohio Valley region is still recovering from the February 27-28 and March 13-15 outbreaks. The last thing they would have needed was a third one.
 
Messages
1,057
Reaction score
814
Location
texas
Question…with regards to historical data what's the different between positively tilted and negatively tilted troughs likelihood to bust or not perform optimally?
 

jiharris0220

Member
Messages
312
Reaction score
792
Location
Wichita Falls
In KY, IN and OH, we really dodged a bullet. Unfortunately it looks like there was some damage, but it could have been a lot worse.

What I find interesting is that the storm mode and evolution were literally as forecast - if anything even better with a good 6 or 7 discrete storms. Yet storms really struggled to produce tornadoes. Clearly, there was something wrong with the environment, but I just can't really figure out what. That Nashville observed sounding was one of the most impressive observed soundings we've seen in a while, and I can only imagine instability would have been greater further north. Clearly we have a long way to go to fully understand tornadoes!
It was the lack of buoyancy, very subpar lapse rates that led to very weak updrafts.
Storms were simply too anemic to take advantage of the kinematics regardless of how favorable.
What would’ve been an easy mid level dry air layer for storms to punch through might as well have been a cap with the weak lift.
The weak forcing would’ve been a favorable factor had it not been for lapse rates barely going over -6c per km and dropping below even that once night fell.
The proof of all of this is every cell in the warm sector look very oblong/disorganized, (no real classic supercell shape) and small. Another clue was looking at the cloud tops, as most cells during the day barely had -50 at coldest. The thin updrafts were simply not capable of reaching those 50000-60000ft heights that would’ve really help in taping into that deep layer shear.
Context clues also lay with the tornadoes themselves, as all of them were of cyclical nature and never long tracked despite extremely favorable wind profiles.
 
Last edited:

MichelleH

Moderator
Moderator
Messages
911
Reaction score
1,377
Location
Cullman, AL
Considering the potential that was there was for yesterday, with the end result being possible dead, injured, homeless, loss of businesses, etc. - I'm quite happy with a "bust," even though it wasn't. There were some tornadoes, just not what was expected. Honestly, anyone that gets upset that there wasn't mass destruction, people killed or maimed from flying debris and communities devastated, needs to have their head examined and doesn't deserve to be considered part of the weather community. Today is the 50th anniversary of the 1974 Super Outbreak. If anyone is upset that yesterday was not a repeat (and not here, but there were morons elsewhere saying it would be), they need to reread the accounts of that horrific day/night. I will be thankful for a "bust" EVERY SINGLE TIME because I KNOW what these things will do. Moving on. /rant
 

JPWX

Member
Messages
1,522
Reaction score
4,132
Location
Smithville MS
Considering the potential that was there was for yesterday, with the end result being possible dead, injured, homeless, loss of businesses, etc. - I'm quite happy with a "bust," even though it wasn't. There were some tornadoes, just not what was expected. Honestly, anyone that gets upset that there wasn't mass destruction, people killed or maimed from flying debris and communities devastated, needs to have their head examined and doesn't deserve to be considered part of the weather community. Today is the 50th anniversary of the 1974 Super Outbreak. If anyone is upset that yesterday was not a repeat (and not here, but there were morons elsewhere saying it would be), they need to reread the accounts of that horrific day/night. I will be thankful for a "bust" EVERY SINGLE TIME because I KNOW what these things will do. Moving on. /rant
In my opinion, a bust is when absolutely nothing happens (hail/damaging winds/tornadoes). And you are absolutely correct!
 

Cood101

Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
25
Location
Pittsburgh PA
Considering the potential that was there was for yesterday, with the end result being possible dead, injured, homeless, loss of businesses, etc. - I'm quite happy with a "bust," even though it wasn't. There were some tornadoes, just not what was expected. Honestly, anyone that gets upset that there wasn't mass destruction, people killed or maimed from flying debris and communities devastated, needs to have their head examined and doesn't deserve to be considered part of the weather community. Today is the 50th anniversary of the 1974 Super Outbreak. If anyone is upset that yesterday was not a repeat (and not here, but there were morons elsewhere saying it would be), they need to reread the accounts of that horrific day/night. I will be thankful for a "bust" EVERY SINGLE TIME because I KNOW what these things will do. Moving on. /rant
 

Attachments

  • 6zrsn7.gif
    6zrsn7.gif
    1.9 MB · Views: 0
Messages
151
Reaction score
208
Location
Flowery Branch, GA
HAM Callsign
KM4JKH
Special Affiliations
  1. SKYWARN® Volunteer
Yea, look’s barely ef1 from that aerial so far at least.

I live in the Atlanta metro area. Here is what I saw from the terminal Doppler radar last night. Kinda takes your breath away.
ead1c264fc2ad917bb8e6891bb9b04c1.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top